| Season | Record | PF | PA | Finish |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2025 LaPorta Potty | 9-6 | 1932.6 | 2007.7 | 🥉 |
| 2024 LaPorta Potty | 9-6 | 2075.7 | 1972.6 | 🥉 |
| 2023 Old Dirty Bastard | 4-11 | 1997.3 | 2136.4 | 8 |
| 2022 Old Dirty Bastard | 6-9 | 1884.1 | 2074.8 | 5 |
| 2021 Old Dirty Bastard | 3-12 | 1862 | 2118.1 | 7 |
| 2020 Fear The Stache | 7-7 | 1869.2 | 2009.1 | 7 |
| 2019 OD B | 10-4 | 1995.1 | 1818.7 | 🥉 |
| 2018 OD B | 6-8 | 2047.3 | 2101.6 | 6 |
| 2017 I Drink, And I Know Things | 6-8 | 1843.5 | 1825.4 | 9 |
| 2016 DeAndre El Bano | 6-8 | 1929 | 1876.3 | 6 |
| 2015 Hoyer The Destroyer | 11-3 | 1978.2 | 1766.3 | 🥉 |
| 2014 Old Dirty Bastard | 10-4 | 1948 | 1687 | 🏆 |
| 2013 Old Dirty Bastard | 6-8 | 1977 | 1987 | 8 |
| 2012 Old Dirty Bastard | 6-8 | 1959 | 1980 | 5 |
| 2011 Old Dirty Bastard | 5-8-1 | 1912 | 2009 | 7 |
| 2010 Old Dirty Bastard | 9-5 | 1961 | 1778 | 🏆 |
| 2009 Old Dirty Bastard | 9-5 | 1878 | 1799 | 4 |
| 2008 Old Dirty Bastard | 10-4 | 2425 | 2227 | 🥈 |
| Opponent | Record | Win% | PF | PA |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Brandon Lowe 2-3 in playoffs | 17-15-1 | 51.5% | 5128.8 | 5007.6 |
| Devin Nicholson 3-1 in playoffs | 16-16 | 50% | 5086.9 | 4921 |
| Mike Rossi 2-3 in playoffs | 12-16 | 42.9% | 4628.6 | 4891.3 |
| Kevin Malina 1-2 in playoffs | 12-16 | 42.9% | 4147.5 | 4431.7 |
| Mike Brown 2-0 in playoffs | 13-14 | 48.1% | 3894.3 | 3801.8 |
| Austin Kobe 1-2 in playoffs | 15-10 | 60% | 3716.5 | 3643.5 |
| Chad Rissland 4-2 in playoffs | 16-8 | 66.7% | 4603.1 | 4207.5 |
| Ernie Rossi 2-0 in playoffs | 6-10 | 37.5% | 2354.5 | 2375.5 |
| John Nicholson 2-0 in playoffs | 6-7 | 46.2% | 2108.1 | 2060.9 |
| Chris Carmichael 2-1 in playoffs | 6-7 | 46.2% | 2121 | 2025.8 |
| Steve Bazaar 0-1 in playoffs | 9-3 | 75% | 1809 | 1648 |
| Matt Meyerhoff | 2-0 | 100% | 432 | 318 |
| Ray Blakely | 1-1 | 50% | 247 | 272 |
| Chris Rossi | 1-1 | 50% | 261.9 | 272.3 |