| Season | Record | PF | PA | Finish |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2015 Matadors 7-0 | 4-10 | 1613.2 | 1889.5 | 10 |
| 2014 Matadors 7-0 | 6-8 | 1596 | 1792 | 9 |
| 2013 Matadors 7-0 | 9-5 | 1906 | 1773 | 🏆 |
| 2012 Matadors 7-0 | 6-8 | 1978 | 2037 | 7 |
| 2011 Matadors 7-0 | 13-1 | 2239 | 1834 | 🥈 |
| 2010 Matadors 7-0 | 12-2 | 2069 | 1645 | 🥈 |
| 2009 Matadors 7-0 | 6-8 | 1902 | 1917 | 6 |
| 2008 Matadors 7-0 | 5-9 | 2182 | 2372 | 5 |
| Opponent | Record | Win% | PF | PA |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Devin Nicholson 1-2 in playoffs | 10-6 | 62.5% | 2508.6 | 2405.9 |
| Mike Rossi 1-0 in playoffs | 8-8 | 50% | 2496.3 | 2446.8 |
| Steve Bazaar 2-0 in playoffs | 7-7 | 50% | 2319 | 2132 |
| Chris Nicholson 0-2 in playoffs | 7-6 | 53.8% | 2060.9 | 2108.1 |
| Chad Rissland 0-1 in playoffs | 5-7 | 41.7% | 1744.7 | 1791.1 |
| Austin Kobe 2-2 in playoffs | 7-4 | 63.6% | 2273.7 | 2167.7 |
| Brandon Lowe 2-0 in playoffs | 6-5 | 54.5% | 1856 | 1717 |
| Mike Brown | 4-4 | 50% | 945.6 | 1046.4 |
| Kevin Malina 1-0 in playoffs | 3-2 | 60% | 800.1 | 732.6 |
| Ray Blakely | 2-0 | 100% | 321 | 301 |
| Matt Meyerhoff | 1-1 | 50% | 265 | 303 |
| Ernie Rossi | 1-1 | 50% | 211.5 | 213.8 |